World Development Report 2004: through the lenses of Marketing of Education Service in India
Dr. Amalesh Bhowal, Professor, Department University.
E-mail: amalesh_b1@rediffmail.com
1.1 Introduction:
Article 10, contained in the Declaration On The Responsibilities Of The Present Generation Towards Future Generations, mentions that “ The present generations should ensure the conditions of equitable, sustainable and universal socio-economic development generations… Education is an important instrument…”
There is a new looking at the world of education using the lenses of marketing. Evidence is the General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS). It aimed at deregulating international markets in services, including education. Corollary: Education is a commodity too which can be traded; in other words, there exists ‘Educational Service Market. To operate in that market, we need Principles and Theories for Marketing of idea behind these principles is the creation of a open, global market place where services, like be traded… GATS covers the educational services of all countries whose educational systems are not exclusively the public sector, or those educational systems that have commercial purposes.”
In the mean time, the World Bank has published “World Development Report 2004 – Making Services Work for Poor People”. It provides a practical framework for making the services that contribute to ‘human development work’ for poor people . The report included services that have the with human development – education, health, water, sanitation, and electricity.
1.2 Main Objective of the paper:
In the backdrop of the above-mentioned International Prescriptions, the paper attempted to explore about the rationality of application of Principles of lessons to be learnt from World Development Report 2004 regarding Marketing of Education Service.
1.3 Rationality of
This type of study may lead to the understanding of the debate whether “Marketing of Education Service” is synonymous with the “Commercialisation of Education Service”.
2.1 Marketing of Education Service [MES]:
Marketing of Education Service refers to [either with profit motive or service motive] which directs the flow of educational goods and services from the producer, provider and developer to the consumer of goods and services to satisfy the needs of policy makers, provider and customers] like Psychological, economic and safety, Social, esteem and self-actualisation needs.
2.2 Current Failure of MES:
Current Education Services to the poor are failing poor people due to: -
[1] Diversion of large share education budget spending towards the non-poor,
[2] Non-reaching of the share of the budget, directed to the the front line service providers
[3] Disincentives to service providers, Prevalence of public corruption and undesirable political
[4] Lower level demand for education because of cultural factors.
Thus, education failed because of over dominance of Finance function; and under importance of Marketing Function.
2.3 Rationality Of Adopting The Principles Of Service Marketing In MES:
“putting poor people at the centre of the service provision”. This is akin to the thinking centric marketing of Srvices. The societies, generally, choose the long route because there are evidences of market failures. Similarly the societies feel traditional short route [i.e. consumers’ power over providers] is inadequate viewed from there exists evidences of the “government failures” associated with the long route; and, “ they may be that, in some cases, the market solution may actually leave poor people better off ”. This is